How to evaluate an acquisition opportunity: strategic fit, due diligence, price and risk
As a chief executive, you are always looking for ways to grow your business, and mergers and acquisitions (M&A) are one of them. But how do you know whether an acquisition opportunity is right for your company? Here is what to look at when you evaluate an acquisition opportunity:
4 criteria for evaluating an acquisition opportunity
Strategic fit
One of the most important questions when you evaluate an acquisition opportunity is whether the target company is a good strategic fit for your business. The target should complement your company’s strengths and help you reach your long-term objectives. For example, if you run a small software company, acquiring a larger hardware business could give you the scale and distribution channels you need to compete in your market.
Due diligence: the checks you cannot skip
The second key consideration is due diligence: the process of investigating the target company to make sure it is a sound financial investment. You will want to examine the target’s financial statements, products, customers and competitive position. Being thorough at this stage helps you avoid unpleasant surprises further down the line.
The right price
You also need to be sure you are paying a fair price for the target company. Overpaying for an acquisition can put your whole business at risk. Make sure you have the right tools or advice to value the target company properly.
The risks
The question to ask yourself is which risks come with the transaction. What are the execution risks? What regulatory risk does the deal carry? What reputational risk does it carry? Answering these questions shows you which risks need to be managed to bring the transaction to a successful completion.
Valuation methods for a target company
To arrive at “the right price”, several methods are usually cross-checked to produce a consistent valuation range rather than a single figure. You can test different scenarios with our business loan calculator.
Multiples (EBITDA, turnover)
A multiple observed on comparable companies is applied to one of the target’s financial metrics. Quick and widely used for SMEs and mid-sized companies.
Discounted cash flow (DCF)
Value is estimated from the expected future cash flows, discounted back to their present value. Suited to companies with a predictable trajectory.
Adjusted net asset value
Each asset and liability is restated at market value to obtain an asset-based value. Relevant for asset-heavy businesses (property, industry).
Comparable transactions
This method uses the prices actually paid in recent deals for similar targets to set a market range.
Conclusion: evaluate every acquisition opportunity before you commit
Mergers and acquisitions can be an excellent way to grow your business, but each opportunity deserves a careful evaluation. Make sure the target company is the right strategic fit, that you have carried out proper due diligence and that you are paying a fair price. Only then should you go ahead with the acquisition.
From first reading to decision: a step-by-step analysis
The four criteria set out above take on their full meaning when they are applied in a precise order. The aim is to quickly rule out the files that are not a fit, and to reserve in-depth analysis, which is more costly in time and fees, for the targets that deserve it. Here is the typical sequence you can follow when you receive a file.
- The strategic filter. When reading the teaser or the first presentation, there is only one question: does the target match the acquisition thesis (business, region, size, type of customer base)? If the answer needs lengthy justification, it is usually a no. Our five-question grid for assessing a target helps formalise this first screening.
- The quality of earnings. Before talking about price, you need to understand what the business really earns. Exceptional items are restated, as is the owner's remuneration if it departs from a normal level, and rent paid to a related company. You then check that earnings actually convert into cash: growing working capital requirements or deferred capital expenditure can make good accounting profits misleading.
- Synergies, measured with caution. Cost synergies, which are easier to quantify and achieve, are distinguished from revenue synergies, which are more uncertain. A widespread rule of prudence is not to include them in the price paid to the seller: they reward the buyer's integration work, which our guide to post-acquisition integration details.
- Compatibility with financing. A price is only acceptable if it can be financed without weakening the whole. In practice, you check that the cash generated by the target and the buyer can repay the acquisition debt in a conservative scenario, with reference to the ratios reviewed by banks.
- The ceiling price. The last step, often forgotten: setting, before the negotiation, the price above which you walk away. This ceiling, set dispassionately on the basis of the valuation methods and the risks identified, protects against end-of-negotiation enthusiasm.
The most frequent mistakes, moreover, stem less from a flawed method than from an oversight: dependence on one customer or one key person, catch-up investment, non-transferable contracts. The audits carried out after the letter of intent is signed are designed precisely to reveal them, as our page on due diligence and the “garantie d’actif et de passif” (warranty and indemnity) explains.
Frequently asked questions about evaluating an acquisition
What is due diligence in an acquisition?
Due diligence is the in-depth review of the target — financial, legal, tax, employment and commercial — carried out before the acquisition to check that the information provided is accurate and to identify the risks before you commit.
How do you value a target company?
The most common methods are multiples (EBITDA, turnover), discounted cash flow (DCF), adjusted net asset value and comparable transactions. Several approaches are usually cross-checked to arrive at a valuation range.
How do I know whether I am paying the right price?
By comparing the valuation produced by several methods with the asking price, taking into account the expected synergies and the risks identified in due diligence. An M&A adviser helps you put the price on an objective footing and structure the negotiation.
Which risks should you check before an acquisition?
Beyond execution, regulatory and reputational risk, you need to examine financial risks (debt, cash), legal, tax and employment risks, as well as any cultural mismatch between the teams.
Sources and references
- Taking control of a company by buying its shares — Bpifrance Création
- Summary tables of the legal structures for a business takeover — Bpifrance Création
- Code de commerce, art. L430-1 to L430-10 — merger control — Légifrance
Content written and reviewed by the Collaboration Capital team. These references are provided for information only and do not replace legal or tax advice tailored to your situation.
Have a target in mind? Have it assessed.
Our team assesses the strategic fit, runs the due diligence and puts the price on an objective footing to secure your deal.
Request a confidential discussionUn premier échange de 30 minutes avec un associé pour cadrer votre projet de cession, d'acquisition ou de financement — sans engagement.
Reply within 24 business hours
Confidentiality guaranteed — NDA on request
IOBSP broker registered with ORIAS under no. 25000696